Japanese Pokémon players long for a cozy sandbox game, not more battles

Perhaps prompted by recent Palworld discourse and comparisons, Japanese users have been voicing their ideas about what their ideal Pokémon game would be like. It seems that a large portion of Pokémon lovers have grown tired of battle and would do anything for a cozier, life simulator-kind of take on Pokémon. 

Post translation: On a completely unrelated note, I really want a game where you can just cohabit with Pokémon casually – like doing stuff around the farm and house, travelling and whatnot. We get snippets of various possibilities through trading cards and other media, but when it comes to games, all you can do is be a trainer and battle… 
I just want to be one of those common folks that live in the Pokémon world. 

Japanese concept artist Le Yamamura shared this sentiment in an X thread posted on January 23, which has since accumulated over 81k likes and 14k reposts. Amidst the recent trend of battle-oriented Pokémon titles, Yamamura expresses hope for a more peaceful and comfy Pokémon game in the future. Rather than being a trainer each time, “living a regular life in the Pokémon world,” is certainly an appealing idea. 

Pokémon Scarlet and Violet battle

In a subsequent post, they describe their ideal game as something that mixes elements of Dragon Quest Builders 2 and Animal Crossing with the addition of Pokémon. While the 2018 sandbox RPG Dragon Quest Builders 2 does include some battle, it also has a whole lot of building, crafting, cooking and exploration. Yamamura goes on to make an even more detailed account of what they mean: 

Post translation: My fantasy of a sandbox game set in the Pokémon world: 
Vast land like in (Dragon Quest) Builders 2 
A few story elements 
A slow-paced simulator approach like Animal Crossing 
Shops and facilities like in Animal Crossing 
Other city dwellers like in Builders 2 
High level of freedom when building like in Builders 2 
The room system of Builders 2 
Farming 
You can have Pokémon help you with building like in Builders 2 
You can go on journeys with Pokémon like in Builders 2 
You can encounter wild Pokémon 
You can raise/evolve Pokémon
Commands for showing Pokémon affection 

If there was a game like this, I would be willing to pay any amount 

In response, many users agreed with the notion and suggested their own ideas for relaxing Pokémon games. The concept of an Animal Crossing- or Story of Seasons-type Pokémon game seemed to be particularly popular.  

Pikachu watching TV in Pokémon Channel from 2003

The topic also triggered some nostalgia for past Pokémon games that were not battle-oriented, such as the 2003 slow-paced virtual pet simulator Pokémon Channel, in which you watch TV with Pikachu, and the 1998 Hey You, Pikachu!, an interactive Pikachu simulator in which you can talk to Pikachu via voice recognition software and gather items. 

Post translation: Now is precisely the time to release something like Hey You, Pikachu! If you add extra elements to it such as home building, gardening and picnics, it will definitely sell. 

While these titles were targeted towards children, many Pokémon fans wish for them to would like them to get remakes that would include more Pokémon and a wider scope of gameplay. 

Post translation: I really want to play a game like that…I just want to live with an Eevee, give it food, go on trips sometimes, take pictures together… 

Over the course of its 30-year history, Pokémon has captivated players with its unique worldbuilding and creature design, but it seems people are starting to seek for different ways to interact with the Pokémon world and the Pokémon themselves, with battle becoming less popular. 

Amber V
Amber V

Novice Editor-in-Chief since October 2023.

She grew up playing Duke Nukem and Wolfenstein with her dad, and is now enamored with obscure Japanese video games and internet culture. Currently devoted to growing Automaton West to the size of its Japanese sister-site, while making sure to keep news concise and developer stories deep and stimulating.

Articles: 440

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CAPTCHA