No politics in my military game, please. Kantai Collection developers criticized for political commentary on official channels 

C2 Kikan, the developers of Kantai Collection, have garnered criticism for openly commenting on modern politics via official channels.

C2 Kikan, the developer behind fleet simulator game Kantai Collection, has caught heat from Japanese players for using its official X account to comment on the country’s recent elections. Much of the criticism comes from fans who don’t want to see any kind of political commentary coming from the game’s official channels, especially given the franchise’s very pronounced military themes and aesthetics. 

Kantai Collection is a free-to-play browser game and multimedia franchise with a 12-year-long history. Published by DMM Games, the game revolves around “fleet girls” – personified versions of real-life warships from WWII. While most of the characters are representations of battleships, cruisers and submarines belonging to the Imperial Japanese Navy, foreign navies like the Soviet Navy, United States Navy and Nazi Germany’s Kriegsmarine make an appearance too. 

Although it’s based on WWII, Kantai Collection doesn’t pit any of the fleet girls against each other, instead setting the conflict between humanity and mysterious hostile beings referred to as the Abyssal Fleet (explained in canon-adjacent media as either the corrupted souls of sunken fleet girls or an extraterrestrial race). 

While the game has undoubtedly sparked an admiration for the Imperial Japanese Navy in some people, a good chunk of Kantai Collection’s Japanese playerbase is careful about drawing the line between being just a military history “geek” (otaku) and being an actual militarist. This could be why C2’s recent post has caused so much dissatisfaction, with several veteran players even announcing their “retirements” from the game. 

The statement in question was posted on October 21, after it was announced that conservative Sanae Takaichi was elected Japan’s first female prime minister. C2 offered words of congratulation to Takaichi, but it also made a jab directed at people who don’t support the new PM and her political party, collectively referring to such people as “unsavory individuals,” or more literally, “no-good people” who feel threatened.  

This second part seems to be what struck a nerve with the hundreds of angry commenters, who felt the alienating phrasing went against the values Kantai Collection should stand for. Below are some of the most supported responses.

Why was it necessary to post this from the official C2 account? 
All of the industry’s efforts to depoliticize military-related hobbies in a positive way have just gone to waste. 
People used to say that it was thanks to Kantai Collection and Girls und Panzer that military hobbies became socially acceptable, but I guess that was just wishful thinking (the fact that there was no one to stop this from being posted internally is telling) 
Hi, I’m one of those “unsavory individuals,” and I feel like the time has come for me to quit this game. I believe that portraying war and weapons positively in creative works is only acceptable if you have a firm stance against their real-world equivalents. I’ve seen statements and actions that blurred that line many times before, but this time, it completely crossed the line for me. 
As a moderate leftist whose ideology is diametrically opposed to Ms. Takaichi’s, I want to make one thing clear. Personally, while I cannot support her ideologically, I’m still eager to see how she performs going forward. However, what exactly do you mean by “unsavory individuals” in this post? Please don’t forget that your players could be part of the group you’re criticizing. 
Amber V
Amber V

Editor-in-Chief since October 2023.

She grew up playing Duke Nukem and Wolfenstein with her dad, and is now enamored with obscure Japanese video games and internet culture. Currently devoted to growing Automaton West to the size of its Japanese sister-site, while making sure to keep news concise and developer stories deep and stimulating.

Articles: 1133

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *